The Gemini Brief- Investment Deep Dives

An In-Depth Analysis of Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (ANZ.AU)

All investment deep dives on this site have been written by Google Gemini with light human editing. Nothing on this site constitutes investment advise. All materials on this site are for informational purposes only.

The Gemini Brief - Investment Deep Dives
The Gemini Brief – Investment Deep Dives
An In-Depth Analysis of Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (ANZ.AU)
Loading
/

Executive Summary

This report provides a comprehensive fundamental analysis of Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (ANZ), one of the four major banks in Australia. The analysis indicates that ANZ is at a pivotal point in its strategic evolution, characterized by a deliberate shift towards strengthening its domestic Australian franchise while leveraging its diversified earnings base. The bank’s performance is underpinned by a market-leading position in New Zealand and a successfully de-risked Institutional division, which together provide earnings stability and the capital to fund a significant transformation in its core Australian market.

The primary strategic thrusts are the acquisition of Suncorp Bank and the development of the ANZ Plus digital banking platform. The Suncorp acquisition, completed in July 2024, is a scale-driven move designed to rectify the bank’s historical underweight position in the high-growth Queensland market. ANZ Plus represents a long-term investment in digital customer engagement, aiming to lower the cost-to-serve and capture a new generation of customers. These initiatives, however, carry substantial integration and execution risks and are being undertaken amidst a challenging macroeconomic environment and an intensely competitive domestic banking landscape.

Financially, ANZ’s performance has been resilient. The FY23 results were strong, benefiting from a rising interest rate cycle, with cash profit increasing 14% to $7.4 billion.1 Performance in the first half of FY24 moderated, with cash profit of $3.55 billion, reflecting the severe margin pressure affecting the entire sector from intense mortgage and deposit competition.3 The bank maintains a robust capital position, with a Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) ratio of 13.5% as of March 2024, well above regulatory requirements and supporting a significant $2 billion on-market share buyback.3 A key consideration for domestic investors is the dividend’s lower franking level, a direct consequence of the significant contribution from its New Zealand and international operations.

Competitively, ANZ remains the fourth-largest of the “Big Four” in the critical Australian housing loan market but holds a dominant number-one position in New Zealand.6 This duality defines its strategic challenge and opportunity. Key risks facing the bank include a potential deterioration in credit quality from a sharper-than-expected economic downturn, execution risk on the Suncorp integration, and the ongoing challenge of converting ANZ Plus deposit-gatherers into profitable, multi-product customers. The current valuation appears to reflect a discount to peers, which may be attributable to its lower Australian market share and the perceived execution risks of its transformation strategy.

Company Profile and Business Model

Founded in 1835, Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd is a multinational banking and financial services company headquartered in Melbourne, Australia.8 It is Australia’s second-largest bank by assets and fourth-largest by market capitalization, serving over 9.5 million customers with a workforce of approximately 40,300 employees.1 The group operates a diversified business model structured across four core divisions, providing a broad range of banking and financial products globally.1

Segmental Analysis

ANZ’s operations are organized into four primary business segments, each contributing uniquely to the group’s overall performance and strategic direction. The balanced contribution from these divisions illustrates the value of the bank’s diversified portfolio.1

  • Australia Retail: This division is the public face of the bank in its home market, offering a comprehensive suite of products including transaction accounts, savings products, mortgages, credit cards, and personal loans to consumer and private banking customers.8 In the first half of the 2024 financial year (1H24), the division demonstrated resilience with strong growth in home loan volumes and a 5% increase in customer deposits.3 For the 2023 financial year (FY23), it generated a strong Return on Equity (ROE) of 14%, excluding the significant investment spend on the ANZ Plus digital platform.11
  • Australia Commercial: This segment is a key engine of profitability, delivering the highest return on equity for the group at 26% in FY23.11 It provides a full range of banking services to small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), agribusiness clients, and high-net-worth individuals, including asset financing and specialized lending.8 In 1H24, this division contributed approximately 19% of group profit, recording robust year-over-year growth of 7% in business lending and 3% in deposits.3
  • Institutional: The Institutional division serves governments, global institutions, and large corporate customers across approximately 30 markets.12 Its offerings include transaction banking, corporate finance, and markets products. Following a strategic de-risking initiative, the division has pivoted towards more capital-efficient activities such as digital payments and currency platforms.1 This transformation has yielded strong results, with the division posting a record ROE in 1H24, driven by a 30% half-on-half increase in customer revenues from its Markets business.3
  • New Zealand: ANZ is the largest bank in New Zealand, where it operates as a full-service bank offering retail, commercial, and wealth management services.7 This division is a cornerstone of the group’s performance, delivering consistent results and a 16% ROE in FY23.11 Despite challenging economic conditions in 1H24, the New Zealand business maintained its market leadership, with lending rising 1% and deposits growing 2%.3

Geographic and Revenue Diversification

ANZ’s geographic footprint provides significant diversification. While Australian operations form the largest part of the business, the New Zealand franchise is a critical contributor to group earnings.9 This geographic mix is a defining feature of ANZ’s investment profile. The strong performance of its businesses outside Australia, particularly in New Zealand, directly impacts shareholder returns. As profits generated in these jurisdictions do not generate Australian franking credits, the group’s dividends are often only partially franked, a key distinction from its more domestically focused peers.1 This structure provides earnings resilience but presents a different tax proposition for Australian investors.

Loan Portfolio Quality and Composition

As of the end of FY23, ANZ’s gross loans and advances stood at $711 billion.1 The composition and quality of this portfolio are central to the bank’s risk profile and profitability.

Composition: Residential mortgages constitute the largest asset class, consistent with the broader Australian banking sector where owner-occupied housing loans make up approximately two-thirds of major bank portfolios.6 In New Zealand, residential mortgages accounted for about 71% of ANZ’s total lending as of June 2024.14 The loan book is further diversified across business lending, agriculture (a key sector in New Zealand, comprising ~10% of the local loan book), and unsecured consumer credit.14

Quality: Management has undertaken a deliberate and consistent strategy to de-risk the loan portfolio since 2016.15 This has involved reducing exposure to historically higher-loss segments while growing lower-risk assets. Key changes include:

  • Reducing unsecured retail lending (personal loans and credit cards) from 7% to 3% of Exposures at Default (EAD).
  • Growing lower-risk segments like mortgages, sovereigns, and banks by $229 billion, increasing their share of EAD from 59% to 64%.
  • Improving the quality of the corporate lending book by increasing the investment-grade component by 70% while reducing non-investment grade lending by approximately one-third.15

This strategic reshaping has resulted in a loan book with a structurally lower risk profile, better positioning the bank to withstand potential credit cycle downturns.

Industry Dynamics and Competitive Positioning

ANZ operates within two distinct but related banking markets: the highly concentrated oligopoly in Australia and the market in New Zealand, where it holds a dominant leadership position. The competitive pressures and regulatory frameworks in each jurisdiction shape the bank’s strategy and performance.

The Australian Oligopoly

The Australian banking system is dominated by the “Big Four” banks—Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA), Westpac Banking Corporation (WBC), National Australia Bank (NAB), and ANZ—which collectively hold approximately 72% of total banking system assets.16 This structure fosters intense competition, particularly in the lucrative residential mortgage market, which has led to significant pressure on profitability across the sector.

ANZ’s market share places it as the fourth largest of the major banks in key retail segments. As of June 2025, its market share in housing loans was approximately 14%, trailing CBA (25%) and Westpac (21%).6 Similarly, in household deposits, ANZ’s share was 13.6% as of July 2024, compared to CBA’s 25.3%.17 This relative underweight position in the core Australian retail market is a significant strategic challenge and provides the primary rationale for its acquisition of Suncorp Bank, which will lift its combined household deposit share to 16.0% and bolster its presence in the fast-growing Queensland market.17

Australian Major Bank Market Share (as of mid-2024/2025)
CategoryANZCBAWestpac
Housing Loans~14% 625% 621% 6
Household Deposits13.6% 1725.3% 1721.4% 17

The New Zealand Stronghold

In contrast to its position in Australia, ANZ is the undisputed market leader in New Zealand. It is the largest bank in the country with an approximate 30% market share in both lending and deposits.7 As of March 2025, ANZ New Zealand’s total assets stood at NZD $200.9 billion, substantially larger than its nearest competitors.18 Data from the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) shows its key prudential metrics are strong, with a total capital ratio of 17.4%, a non-performing loan (NPL) ratio of 0.9%, and a return on assets (ROA) of 1.4, all of which are comparable to or stronger than its peers.18 This dominant and profitable position provides a stable and significant source of earnings for the group, acting as a partial hedge against the more intense competitive dynamics in Australia.

Competitive Pressures

The competitive landscape is evolving, with pressure coming from both traditional and emerging players.

  • Traditional Banks: The primary source of pressure remains the other major banks, particularly in the mortgage market where intense price-based competition has led to significant Net Interest Margin (NIM) compression across the sector.19
  • Non-Bank and Fintech Lenders: The threat from emerging players is nuanced. While “neobanks” have had limited impact, non-bank lenders and private credit funds are creating significant competition in specific segments like business lending.21 The broader Australian fintech market is projected to more than double in size to USD $9.5 billion by 2033, with payments and Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) being key areas of disruption.22 The strategic threat from fintech is less about direct competition across all products and more about the disintermediation of the customer relationship. By offering superior user experiences in specific verticals, fintechs can capture key customer interactions, weakening the incumbent banks’ ability to gather data and cross-sell higher-margin products. This dynamic underscores the strategic importance of ANZ’s investment in its own digital platform, ANZ Plus.

Regulatory Environment

The banking sector operates under a stringent regulatory framework overseen by the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA).

  • Capital Requirements: APRA’s capital framework, based on international Basel III standards, requires banks to hold “unquestionably strong” levels of capital.23 The minimum CET1 ratio for major banks is effectively 10.5%, including various capital buffers.23 This framework ensures financial system stability and creates high barriers to entry, but it also constrains leverage and influences capital return policies.
  • Open Banking: Australia’s Consumer Data Right (CDR) is being rolled out, with banking as the first designated sector.25 The CDR aims to empower consumers by allowing them to securely share their financial data with accredited third parties, theoretically increasing competition and making it easier to switch providers.26 However, progress has been slow. Consumer adoption remains very low, at just 0.31% of bank customers at the end of 2023, and technical issues such as high consent authorisation failure rates (nearly 30%) have hampered its effectiveness.27 While the long-term potential of Open Banking is significant, its near-term impact on the competitive positions of the major banks has been limited.

Financial Performance Analysis (FY22 – 1H24)

ANZ’s financial performance over the past two years reflects a period of strong earnings driven by a rising interest rate environment, followed by a period of normalization characterized by intense competitive pressure on margins.

Profitability Deep Dive

After a period of strong growth, profitability metrics have begun to moderate.

  • Net Profit: The bank reported a robust 14% increase in cash profit to $7.4 billion in FY23, benefiting from margin expansion.1 However, this momentum slowed in 1H24, with cash profit declining 7% from the prior corresponding period to $3.55 billion, reflecting the challenging operating environment.3
  • Net Interest Margin (NIM): NIM is the primary driver of bank profitability and has been the focal point of market pressure. ANZ’s NIM expanded by 7 basis points in FY23 to 1.70%.30 This trend reversed sharply in 1H24. According to analysis by KPMG, the average NIM for the major banks compressed by 11 basis points year-over-year to 179 basis points, with ANZ recording a NIM of 156 basis points for the half.20 This sector-wide compression is a direct result of aggressive price competition for both housing loans and customer deposits.19
  • Return on Equity (ROE): Cash ROE improved to 10.9% in FY23, an increase of 54 basis points from FY22.1 In 1H24, ROE moderated to 10.1% (or 10.7% excluding capital held for the Suncorp acquisition).3 While solid, this places ANZ’s returns below the sector leader, CBA, which reported a full-year ROE of 13.1% in FY24, compared to ANZ’s 9.4%.31

Operational Efficiency

Management has focused on productivity to offset inflationary pressures and fund strategic investments.

  • Cost-to-Income Ratio: This key efficiency metric showed improvement in FY23, falling to 48.5% from 52.0% in the prior year.30 However, underlying expense pressures remain. In 1H24, operating expenses rose 4% compared to the second half of 2023, driven by inflation and ongoing investment in technology and compliance.29
  • Productivity Initiatives: In its 1H24 results, management highlighted the achievement of $200 million in productivity savings.3 These gains, however, are being realized in a period of significant strategic investment in the Suncorp integration and the ANZ Plus platform. These large-scale projects will likely keep expense growth elevated in the short term, with the ultimate goal of creating a structurally more efficient business in the long run. The trajectory of the cost-to-income ratio will therefore be a critical indicator of the success of these strategic bets.

Asset Quality and Provisioning

Asset quality has remained remarkably resilient despite the rapid increase in interest rates.

  • Credit Impairment Charges: Provisions for bad and doubtful debts remain low. The total credit impairment charge for 1H24 was a modest $70 million.4
  • Loan Delinquencies: While arrears are ticking up from cyclical lows, they remain contained. Mortgage payments 90 or more days past due rose slightly but are still low by historical standards.32 As of March 2024, approximately 79% of ANZ’s home loan customers were ahead on their repayments, providing a substantial buffer against financial stress.3
  • Provisioning Levels: ANZ has maintained a prudent approach to provisioning. Its collective provision balance stood at $4.0 billion at the end of 1H24.29 This balance is $2.2 billion above the bank’s base case economic scenario, indicating a conservative posture and a significant buffer to absorb potential future credit losses.15

Peer Benchmarking

Comparing ANZ’s key metrics against its “Big Four” peers provides essential context for its performance.

Key Financial Metrics Peer Comparison
MetricPeriodANZCBANAB
Net Interest MarginFY231.70% 302.07% 301.74% 30
1H241.56% 201.99% 201.72% 20
Cost-to-Income RatioFY2348.5% 3043.5% 3043.7% 30
FY24 (est.)52.3% 3145.4% 3148.6% 31
Cash Return on EquityFY2310.9% 114.0% 3012.3% 30
FY24 (est.)9.4% 3113.1% 3111.4% 31
CET1 RatioSep 202313.3% 212.2% 3012.2% 30
Mar 202413.5% 311.9% (Q3) 3212.15% 34

Note: CBA’s financial year ends June 30; others end September 30. FY24 figures for ANZ, NAB, WBC are based on full-year analysis from KPMG. CET1 for CBA and WBC are as of their Q3 2024/2025 updates.

The comparison highlights that while ANZ maintains a sector-leading capital position, its core profitability metrics such as NIM and ROE have lagged the market leader, CBA. Its cost-to-income ratio is also higher than CBA and NAB, reflecting its ongoing investment phase.

Strategic Initiatives and Growth Levers

ANZ’s strategy is focused on reshaping its Australian business for long-term growth while leveraging its established strengths in other divisions. The two central pillars of this strategy are the acquisition of Suncorp Bank and the build-out of its digital platform, ANZ Plus.

Digital Banking Transformation (ANZ Plus)

ANZ Plus is the bank’s flagship digital initiative, designed from the ground up as a new technology platform to be the future foundation of its Australian retail business.1

  • Strategy and Objective: Rather than layering new features onto legacy infrastructure, ANZ has built a separate, modern banking platform. The initial focus was on attracting customers and deposits through a high-interest savings account and superior user experience. The strategic priority has now shifted to deepening engagement and converting these users into primary banking customers who use ANZ Plus for transactions, bill payments, and eventually, lending products.4
  • Performance and Traction: The platform has demonstrated significant early success in customer acquisition. As of September 2024, ANZ Plus had attracted 848,000 customers and $16 billion in deposits.37 A key metric of success is that approximately half of these customers are new to ANZ, indicating the platform’s appeal beyond the existing customer base.3

Acquisition and Geographic Expansion (Suncorp Bank)

The acquisition of Suncorp Bank is a transformative move designed to address a key structural weakness in ANZ’s Australian footprint.

  • Strategic Rationale: ANZ has historically been under-represented in Queensland, one of Australia’s fastest-growing states. The Suncorp Bank acquisition provides immediate scale, a strong regional brand, and a significant boost to its customer base, deposit franchise, and mortgage book in this critical market.36
  • Transaction Status: After a lengthy regulatory review process, which included an initial block by the Australian Competition & Consumer Commission (ACCC) that was later overturned by the Australian Competition Tribunal, the acquisition was completed on July 31, 2024.3

Asian Market Strategy

The bank’s approach to Asia has undergone a significant strategic shift over the past decade.

  • From “Super Regional” to Institutional Focus: An earlier strategy aimed to build a “super regional” bank with a major retail and commercial presence across Asia.40 This led to a series of acquisitions, including RBS’s retail and commercial businesses in several Asian countries in 2009-2010.40
  • Strategic Pivot: Under current leadership, this strategy was unwound due to low returns. In 2016-2017, ANZ divested its retail and wealth management operations in Singapore, Hong Kong, China, Taiwan, and Indonesia to DBS Bank, signaling a clear withdrawal from its broad “Asian pivot”.9 The current focus in Asia is squarely on the less capital-intensive, higher-returning Institutional business, which facilitates trade and capital flows for large corporate and institutional clients across the region.

Wealth Management

Similar to its Asian retail strategy, ANZ has largely exited the mass-market wealth management business. This followed industry-wide reputational issues highlighted by the Royal Commission and a strategic decision to simplify the bank. The sale of its 51% stake in the ING Australia joint venture in 2009 was a key step in this process.40 The bank’s current wealth offering is focused on serving the needs of high-net-worth and private banking clients within its Australia Commercial and Retail divisions.44

Capital Allocation & Shareholder Returns

ANZ’s capital management framework is characterized by a strong emphasis on balance sheet resilience, disciplined investment in strategic growth, and the return of surplus capital to shareholders.

Capital Adequacy

ANZ maintains a capital position that is well in excess of regulatory minimums, a cornerstone of its low-risk profile.

  • CET1 Ratio: The Group’s APRA Level 2 Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) ratio stood at an exceptionally strong 13.5% as of March 31, 2024.3 This compares to a ratio of 13.3% at the end of FY23 and 12.3% at the end of FY22, demonstrating consistent capital generation.1
  • Regulatory Buffer: This level is significantly above APRA’s “unquestionably strong” benchmark of 10.5% for major banks, providing a substantial buffer to absorb unexpected losses and navigate economic uncertainty.24 Management has described this position as placing ANZ “among the best capitalised banks in the world”.3

Share Buybacks

The bank’s robust capital position has enabled it to undertake significant capital returns to shareholders via on-market share buybacks.

  • $2 Billion Program: In May 2024, the Board approved a share buyback of up to $2 billion, one of the largest in the bank’s history.3 This was supported by organic capital generation and the capital released from the partial sale of its stake in Malaysia’s AmBank.3 Share buybacks are a flexible and tax-effective method of returning capital, particularly for a company with a partially franked dividend stream.

Dividend Policy

ANZ has a consistent history of paying dividends, though the composition and tax-effectiveness for Australian investors have evolved with the bank’s strategy.

  • Recent Payouts: The total dividend for FY23 was 175 cents per share, a 20% increase from the 146 cents paid in FY22.1 The interim dividend for 1H24 was set at 83 cents per share.3
  • Franking Levels: A critical feature of ANZ’s dividend is its declining franking level. The final dividend for FY23 was only 56% franked, while the 1H24 interim dividend was 65% franked.1 This is a direct result of the group’s successful geographic diversification. A significant portion of earnings is generated in New Zealand and Asia, where Australian corporate tax is not paid, meaning no franking credits are generated to be passed on to Australian shareholders.1

This dynamic presents a clear trade-off for investors. The bank’s capital allocation hierarchy prioritizes balance sheet strength and strategic investment, with shareholder returns as the subsequent priority. The success of its international operations, which contributes to earnings resilience, simultaneously dilutes the tax effectiveness of its dividend for Australian investors. The large-scale buyback can be viewed as a mechanism to offset this, providing a tax-efficient return of capital that complements the partially franked dividend.

Management Quality & Corporate Governance

The quality of an institution’s leadership and the robustness of its governance framework are critical determinants of long-term value creation and risk management.

Leadership Team and Strategic Vision

  • Chief Executive Officer: Shayne Elliott was appointed CEO on January 1, 2016, having previously served as the bank’s Chief Financial Officer.45 His tenure has been marked by a clear strategic vision focused on simplification, de-risking, and strengthening the core franchise. Key initiatives under his leadership include the exit from Asian retail banking and mass-market wealth management, a significant improvement in the bank’s risk profile, and the current dual focus on the Suncorp integration and the ANZ Plus digital transformation.9
  • Executive Committee: The CEO is supported by an experienced executive committee with clear accountability for the group’s core divisions and functions.46 This includes Antonia Watson, CEO of the strategically important New Zealand division, and Clare Morgan, who was appointed Group Executive for Australia Commercial in 2023.44

Corporate Governance

ANZ’s governance framework is designed to ensure effective oversight and responsible decision-making, aligned with shareholder interests.

  • Board Composition: As of August 2023, the Board of the listed entity, ANZ Group Holdings Limited (ANZGHL), is comprised of eight independent Non-Executive Directors and one Executive Director (the CEO, Shayne Elliott). The Board is led by an independent Chair, Paul O’Sullivan.48 This structure ensures a strong majority of independent oversight.
  • Non-Operating Holding Company (NOHC) Structure: In January 2023, ANZ implemented a NOHC structure, establishing ANZGHL as the new listed parent of the group.48 This restructure legally separated the banking group from certain non-banking businesses, a move designed to enhance resolvability and align with evolving regulatory expectations for large, complex financial institutions.
  • Board Committees: The Board is supported by six principal committees that provide detailed oversight of key areas: Audit, Risk, Human Resources, Ethics, Environment, Social and Governance (EESG), Digital Business and Technology, and Nomination and Board Operations.50 This structure ensures that specialized expertise is applied to the most critical areas of the bank’s operations and risk management.
  • Transparency and Disclosure: ANZ provides comprehensive disclosure on its governance practices through its annual Corporate Governance Statement, which outlines its compliance with the ASX Corporate Governance Council’s principles and recommendations.1

Valuation Analysis

Assessing ANZ’s valuation requires a multi-faceted approach, comparing current trading multiples to historical ranges, peer benchmarks, and underlying fundamental drivers. The analysis suggests that while the stock is not trading at historically low multiples, it may offer relative value compared to its domestic peers, reflecting its different risk/return profile.

Trading Multiples and Historical Context

  • Price-to-Earnings (P/E) Ratio: As of mid-2025, ANZ’s trailing twelve-month (TTM) P/E ratio is in a range of 13.6x to 14.6x.52 This represents a notable expansion from its year-end FY23 P/E of 11.0x.55 The stock’s 10-year average P/E ratio is approximately 12.8x, indicating that it is currently trading at a premium to its long-term average.52
  • Price-to-Book (P/B) Ratio: The P/B ratio stands at approximately 1.4x.57 This is a key metric for banks, as it compares the market’s valuation to the accounting value of its equity.
  • Dividend Yield: The forward dividend yield is in the range of 4.97% to 5.47%, a significant component of the total return proposition for bank investors.52

Peer Valuation Comparison

Comparing ANZ’s valuation to its “Big Four” peers reveals important relative positioning.

Valuation Multiples: ANZ vs. Peers (as of mid-2024/2025)
MetricANZCBANABWBC
P/E Ratio13.3x 5330.5x 5315.6x 5316.9x 53
P/B Ratio1.4x 57N/AN/AN/A
Dividend Yield~5.0% 54N/AN/AN/A

Note: Data is sourced from multiple providers and reflects market conditions in mid-2024/2025. CBA’s P/E ratio is a significant outlier.

The data indicates that ANZ trades at a noticeable P/E discount to its major peers, particularly the market leader CBA. This valuation gap may reflect several factors, including ANZ’s lower market share in the core Australian retail market, its historically lower ROE compared to CBA, and the market’s pricing of the execution risks associated with its Suncorp and ANZ Plus strategies.

Key Valuation Drivers

  • Book Value Growth: A primary long-term driver of a bank’s share price is the growth in its tangible book value. ANZ has demonstrated a consistent ability to grow its Net Tangible Assets (NTA) per share, which increased from $20.75 at the end of FY22 to $21.78 at FY23, and further to $22.05 by 1H24.2 Continued profitable growth that adds to this tangible book value is essential for long-term value creation.
  • Dividend Sustainability: The dividend is well-supported by earnings and the bank’s strong capital position. The key variable for investors is not its sustainability but its future growth rate and the level of franking. The partially franked dividend makes direct yield comparisons with fully franked peers less straightforward, as the after-tax return will differ depending on an investor’s tax status.

Risk Assessment

A comprehensive risk assessment is critical to understanding the potential challenges to ANZ’s strategy and financial performance. The bank is exposed to a range of credit, market, operational, and regulatory risks.

Credit Risk

Credit risk, the risk of loss from borrowers failing to meet their obligations, is the most significant risk for a bank.

  • Housing Market Concentration: ANZ has substantial exposure to the Australian and New Zealand residential mortgage markets. A severe economic downturn leading to a sharp rise in unemployment and a significant fall in property prices would inevitably lead to higher loan losses. Mitigating factors include the de-risking of the portfolio, prudent lending standards, and the high proportion of customers who are ahead on their mortgage repayments.3
  • Sector-Specific Exposures: The bank has notable concentrations in commercial real estate (CRE) and agriculture. The New Zealand agriculture portfolio, representing about 10% of the NZ loan book, is exposed to the volatility of global commodity prices and weather events.14 While global CRE markets have experienced stress, the quality and diversification of ANZ’s specific exposures are key determinants of potential losses.
  • Economic Headwinds: The impact of higher inflation and interest rates on household and business finances remains a key uncertainty. While credit quality has been resilient to date, a prolonged period of subdued economic growth could see stress emerge, particularly in the small business and unsecured consumer lending segments.1

Market and Interest Rate Risk

Market risk arises from movements in market variables, primarily interest rates.

  • Net Interest Margin (NIM) Sensitivity: The bank’s profitability is highly sensitive to changes in interest rates and the competitive dynamics that influence lending and deposit pricing. As evidenced in 1H24, intense competition can lead to rapid NIM compression even in a stable interest rate environment, directly impacting revenue and earnings.20

Operational and Cyber Risk

Operational risk is the risk of loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes, people, and systems, or from external events.

  • Technology and Cybersecurity: The bank’s increasing reliance on digital platforms for customer interaction and internal processes makes it a prime target for cyber-attacks. A major security breach could result in significant financial losses, regulatory penalties, and severe reputational damage. APRA has identified strengthening cyber resilience as a top priority for the industry.58
  • Integration Risk: The Suncorp Bank acquisition is a large and complex undertaking. There is a significant risk that the integration of technology systems, business processes, and company cultures could face delays, cost overruns, or fail to deliver the expected revenue synergies and efficiencies.
  • Scams and Fraud: The rising prevalence of sophisticated scams targeting bank customers represents a growing operational and reputational risk for all financial institutions.

Regulatory and Compliance Risk

The banking sector operates in a highly regulated environment, and the risk of non-compliance or adverse regulatory change is ever-present.

  • Post-Royal Commission Scrutiny: The industry continues to operate under heightened regulatory scrutiny following the 2018 Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry. This has resulted in elevated and ongoing compliance costs.
  • New Regulations: The implementation of new regulations, such as APRA’s prudential standard on operational risk (CPS 230) and the Financial Accountability Regime (FAR), adds to the complexity and cost of compliance for the bank.48

Forward-Looking Considerations

Synthesizing the analysis of ANZ’s business, financials, strategy, and risks allows for a balanced assessment of its future prospects and the key factors that will likely drive its performance.

Bull vs. Bear Case Synthesis

  • The Bull Case for ANZ rests on the successful execution of its strategic transformation. Proponents would argue that the Suncorp acquisition will successfully re-weight the bank towards the high-growth Queensland market, improving its domestic earnings profile and market share. They would also point to the rapid customer acquisition of ANZ Plus as evidence of a successful digital strategy that will ultimately lead to a lower cost-to-serve and a more engaged, profitable customer base. Furthermore, the stability and market leadership of the New Zealand business, combined with the strong returns from the de-risked Institutional division, provide a resilient earnings foundation to support this transformation. In this scenario, the current valuation discount to peers would narrow as execution risks subside and the benefits of the strategy flow through to improved ROE.
  • The Bear Case focuses on the significant execution risks and competitive headwinds. Skeptics would argue that large-scale bank integrations are notoriously difficult and that the Suncorp deal could suffer from cost blowouts and a failure to realize synergies. They would question whether ANZ Plus can successfully convert its large base of low-margin savings customers into profitable, multi-product relationships, or if it will remain a costly deposit-gathering exercise. This case would also emphasize the persistent margin pressure in the core Australian mortgage market and ANZ’s ongoing struggle to gain organic market share against more dominant competitors, suggesting that profitability will remain constrained regardless of strategic initiatives.

Key Questions Addressed

  1. How has ANZ’s competitive position evolved relative to peers over the past two years?
    ANZ’s organic competitive position in the Australian retail market has remained challenged, with its market share in housing loans and deposits continuing to lag its major peers.6 However, its strategic position has been decisively altered by the Suncorp acquisition, which represents a significant inorganic step to bolster its scale and presence in a key growth market. In New Zealand, its dominant position has been maintained, while the Institutional division has strengthened its return profile through a successful de-risking strategy.3
  2. What are the main drivers of future profitability and how sustainable are they?
    The primary drivers of future profitability are: (1) the successful integration of Suncorp Bank and the realization of associated cost and revenue synergies; (2) the ability to monetize the ANZ Plus customer base by deepening relationships and cross-selling higher-margin products; and (3) the performance of the New Zealand and Institutional divisions, which provide a sustainable and diversified earnings base. The sustainability of profitability will depend heavily on management’s execution of the first two drivers, as the broader industry faces the persistent headwind of NIM compression.
  3. How well-positioned is ANZ for the current interest rate and economic environment?
    From a balance sheet perspective, ANZ is very well-positioned. Its “unquestionably strong” capital base, high levels of liquidity, and prudent credit provisioning provide a robust defense against economic uncertainty.3 Its diversified earnings streams also offer more resilience than a purely domestic retail-focused bank. However, like all banks, its earnings remain highly sensitive to the health of the Australian and New Zealand economies, particularly the performance of the housing market and the financial well-being of households and small businesses.
  4. What are the key risks that could derail the investment thesis?
    The key risks are threefold:
  • Macroeconomic Risk: A severe recession in Australia or New Zealand leading to a sharp rise in unemployment and significant credit losses would impact all banks, including ANZ.
  • Strategic Execution Risk: A failure to successfully integrate Suncorp Bank or to transition ANZ Plus from a customer acquisition tool to a profitable business line would undermine the core pillars of the bank’s growth strategy.
  • Competitive Risk: An inability to defend and grow market share profitably in the core Australian banking market against larger, more entrenched competitors could lead to a sustained period of underperformance.
  1. How does the current valuation compare to intrinsic value estimates?
    The current valuation, particularly the P/E ratio, trades at a discount to its major Australian peers.53 This suggests the market is pricing in the significant execution risks associated with the Suncorp integration and the ANZ Plus strategy, as well as the bank’s lower market share in Australian retail. An assessment of intrinsic value depends on one’s view of these strategic initiatives. If management successfully executes its plan, the bank’s earnings power and ROE could improve, suggesting that the current market price is below its long-term intrinsic value. Conversely, if the strategic bets fail to deliver, the current valuation discount may be justified or could even widen.

Works cited

  1. ANZ 2023 Annual Report – For personal use only, accessed August 26, 2025, https://announcements.asx.com.au/asxpdf/20231113/pdf/05x8gvgwpd4gjw.pdf
  2. ANNUAL REPORT – ANZ, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com/content/dam/anzcom/shareholder/ANZ-Annual-Report-2023.pdf
  3. 2024 HALF YEAR HIGHLIGHTS – ANZ, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com/content/dam/anzcom/shareholder/shareholder-letter-2024-online.pdf
  4. ANZ announces strong 2024 half-year results | Australian Broker News, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.brokernews.com.au/news/breaking-news/anz-announces-strong-2024-halfyear-results-284657.aspx
  5. 2024 Half Year Result & Proposed Dividend – Mirage News, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.miragenews.com/2024-half-year-result-proposed-dividend-1229167/
  6. Australia’s largest lenders report $15 billion rise in loan portfolios – Mortgage Professional, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.mpamag.com/au/news/general/australias-largest-lenders-report-15-billion-rise-in-loan-portfolios/546362
  7. ANZ Bank New Zealand – Wikipedia, accessed August 26, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ANZ_Bank_New_Zealand
  8. Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited – AnnualReports.com, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.annualreports.com/Company/australia-new-zealand-banking-group-limited
  9. ANZ (bank) – Wikipedia, accessed August 26, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ANZ_(bank)
  10. Annual Report / Annual Review Shareholders Centre | ANZ, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com/shareholder/centre/reporting/annual-report-annual-review/
  11. 2023 Full Year Results | ANZ, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com/content/dam/anzcom/shareholder/ANZGHL-full-year-2023-results-investor-discussion-pack.pdf
  12. Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (ASX:ANZ) Share Price – Market Index, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.marketindex.com.au/asx/anz
  13. Australia and New Zealand Banking | ANZ – Stock Price | Live Quote | Historical Chart, accessed August 26, 2025, https://tradingeconomics.com/anz:nz
  14. ANZ Bank New Zealand Ltd., accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com/content/dam/anzcom/debtinvestors/sp-report-anznz%20Report-2024-10-10.pdf
  15. BEHIND THE NUMBERS: Risk Off – transforming for a safer bank | ANZ, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com.au/bluenotes/2023/05/anz-news-risk-simplify-customer-future-btn-results23/
  16. Review into Small and Medium-sized Banks – Council of Financial Regulators, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.cfr.gov.au/publications/consultations/2024/review-into-small-and-medium-sized-banks/pdf/review-into-small-and-medium-sized%20banks-issues-paper.pdf
  17. Household deposits hit $1.5 trillion: APRA – RateCity, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.ratecity.com.au/savings-accounts/news/household-deposits-hit1-5-trillion-apra
  18. Key metric summary, accessed August 26, 2025, https://bankdashboard.rbnz.govt.nz/
  19. Resilience of the Australian Financial System | Financial Stability Review – March 2024, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.rba.gov.au/publications/fsr/2024/mar/resilience-of-the-australian-financial-system.html
  20. Major Australian banks: half year 2024 results analysis – KPMG International, accessed August 26, 2025, https://kpmg.com/au/en/insights/industry/big-four-major-australian-banks-half-year-results-2024.html
  21. Harbour Navigator: Technology, competition and risk are reshaping Australian banking, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.harbourasset.co.nz/research-and-commentary/technology-competition-and-risk-are-reshaping-australian-banking
  22. Australia Fintech Market Size, Share & Industry Report, 2033 – IMARC, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.imarcgroup.com/australia-fintech-market
  23. Capital explained | APRA, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.apra.gov.au/capital-explained
  24. Australian Prudential Regulation Authority – ACCC, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.accc.gov.au/system/files/public-registers/documents/Submission%20by%20Australian%20Prudential%20Regulation%20Authority%20-%2013.07.23%20-%20PR%20-%20MA1000023%20ANZ%20Suncorp.pdf
  25. Rollout | Consumer Data Right, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.cdr.gov.au/rollout
  26. Open banking: switch or stick? Insights into customer switching behaviour and trust – Australian Banking Association, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.ausbanking.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Open-Banking-Switch-or-Stick-Insights-Into-Customer-Switching-Behaviour-and-Trust-Deloitte-2019.pdf
  27. The impact of open banking in Australia and New Zealand | Acuity, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.acuitymag.com/finance/the-impact-of-open-banking-in-australia-and-new-zealand
  28. Frollo: Report finds growing momentum behind Open Banking in Australia, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.openbankingexpo.com/news/frollo-report-finds-growing-momentum-behind-open-banking-in-australia/
  29. ANZ 1H 2024 Results Presentation & Investor Discussion Pack – Listcorp, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.listcorp.com/asx/an3/profile/news/anz-1h-2024-results-presentation-and-amp-investor-discussion-pack-3028632.html
  30. Major Australian Banks Full Year 2023 Results – KPMG International, accessed August 26, 2025, https://assets.kpmg.com/content/dam/kpmg/au/pdf/2023/major-australian-banks-full-year-2023-analysis.pdf
  31. Australian Big Four Banks: Full year 2024 results analysis – KPMG International, accessed August 26, 2025, https://kpmg.com/au/en/insights/industry/australian-big-4-major-banks-full-year-results-2024.html
  32. ANZ posts Q3 lending and deposit growth amid housing resilience | Australian Broker News, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.brokernews.com.au/news/breaking-news/anz-posts-q3-lending-and-deposit-growth-amid-housing-resilience-287809.aspx
  33. Australian lender ANZ reports rise in Q3 loans and deposits By Reuters – Investing.com, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.investing.com/news/stock-market-news/australian-lender-anz-reports-rise-in-deposits-loans-in-third-quarter-4194266
  34. 2024 Half Year Results Summary – National Australia Bank Limited (ASX:NAB) – Listcorp., accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.listcorp.com/asx/nab/national-australia-bank-limited/news/2024-half-year-results-summary-3026937.html
  35. ANZ 2022 Annual Report – For personal use only, accessed August 26, 2025, https://announcements.asx.com.au/asxpdf/20221103/pdf/45h6fm0h1pwyx1.pdf
  36. 2024 Full Year Results | ANZ, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com/content/dam/anzcom/shareholder/2024-anzghl-full-year-results-presentation-and-investor-discussion-pack.pdf
  37. 2024 Annual Report | ANZ, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com.au/content/dam/anzcom/shareholder/ANZGHL-2024-Annual%20Report.pdf
  38. ANZ Half Year Results, Dividend Announcement & Appendix 4D – Listcorp, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.listcorp.com/asx/an3/profile/news/anz-half-year-results-dividend-announcement-and-amp-appendix-4d-3187111.html
  39. ANZ’s Super Regional Strategy Five-Year Progress Report, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com/content/dam/anzcom/shareholder/58389%20ANZ%20Regional%20YR5%20LR.pdf
  40. ANZ completes acquisition of RBS retail and commercial businesses in Hong Kong (PDF 28kB), accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com.au/newsroom/media/2010/03/anz-completes-acquisition-of-rbs-retail-and-commercial-businesse/
  41. DBS completes acquisition of ANZ’s retail and wealth business in Hong Kong, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.dbs.com/hongkong/newsroom/DBS_COMPLETES_ACQUISITION_OF_ANZ
  42. DBS TO ACQUIRE ANZ’S WEALTH MANAGEMENT AND RETAIL BANKING BUSINESS IN SINGAPORE, HONG KONG, MAINLAND CHINA, TAIWAN AND INDONESIA, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.dbs.com/china-sc/newsroom/DBS_TO_ACQUIRE_ANZ_WEALTH_MANAGEMENT_AND_RETAIL_BANKING_BUSINESS_IN_SINGAPORE_HONG_KONG_MAINLAND_CHINA_TAIWAN_AND_INDONESIA
  43. Clare Morgan | ANZ, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com/content/dam/anzcom/shareholder/clare-morgan-bio.pdf
  44. Shayne Elliott to succeed Mike Smith as ANZ CEO, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com.au/newsroom/media/2015/10/shayne-elliott-to-succeed-mike-smith-as-anz-ceo/
  45. ANZ Executive Committee – Shareholder Centre, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com/shareholder/centre/about/executive-committee/
  46. ANZ New Zealand Org Chart + Executive Team – The Official Board, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.theofficialboard.com/org-chart/anz-new-zealand
  47. 2023 – corporate governance statement – ANZ, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com/content/dam/anzcom/shareholder/ANZ-Corporate-Governance-Statement-2023.pdf
  48. Corporate Governance Shareholder Centre – ANZ, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.anz.com/shareholder/centre/about/corporate-governance/
  49. ANZ Corporate Governance Statement 2023 | PDF – Scribd, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.scribd.com/document/724766853/ANZ-Corporate-Governance-Statement-2023
  50. ANZ 2023 Annual Review – ANZ Group Holdings Limited (ASX:ANZ) – Listcorp., accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.listcorp.com/asx/anz/anz-group-holdings-limited/news/anz-2023-annual-review-2955343.html
  51. ANZ Group Holdings Limited – PE Ratio – Wisesheets, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.wisesheets.io/pe-ratio/ANZ.AX
  52. ANZ Banking | ANZ – PE Price to Earnings – Trading Economics, accessed August 26, 2025, https://tradingeconomics.com/anz:au:pe
  53. ANZ Group Holdings Ltd Stock Price Today | ASX – Investing.com, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.investing.com/equities/australia—nz-banking-grp-ltd
  54. ANZ Bank (ANZ.AX) – P/E ratio – Companies Market Cap, accessed August 26, 2025, https://companiesmarketcap.com/anz-bank/pe-ratio/
  55. ANZ Group Holdings Limited – PE Ratio – Wisesheets, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.wisesheets.io/pe-ratio/ANZGY
  56. ANZ P/B – Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd – Alpha Spread, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.alphaspread.com/security/asx/anz/relative-valuation/ratio/price-to-book-value
  57. ASIC publishes 2025-26 Corporate Plan | Global Regulation Tomorrow, accessed August 26, 2025, https://www.regulationtomorrow.com/au/asic-publishes-2025-26-corporate-plan/